Carolina Panthers (1999-2003) vs New York Giants (1999-2003)

A simulated 7-game series between two all-time rosters, scored by our era-adjusted rating model. Carolina Panthers take it 4-0.

Carolina Panthers · 1999-2003

Squad power 85.2 · headliner Wesley Walls '99 (91)

QBSteve Beuerlein (85) · Jake Delhomme (75) · Rodney Peete (72)

RBStephen Davis (78) · Tim Biakabutuka (76) · Lamar Smith (71)

WRPatrick Jeffers (85) · Muhsin Muhammad (83) · Steve Smith (79)

TEWesley Walls (91)

EDGEKevin Greene (88) · Julius Peppers (85) · Mike Rucker (84)

DTKris Jenkins (88) · Brentson Buckner (79) · Sean Gilbert (75)

LBMicheal Barrow (77) · Lester Towns (73) · Lee Woodall (72)

CBDoug Evans (88) · Terry Cousin (78) · Ricky Manning (75)

SEric Davis (86) · Mike Minter (80) · Deon Grant (79)

New York Giants · 1999-2003

Squad power 83.6 · headliner Michael Strahan '01 (99)

QBKerry Collins (78) · Kent Graham (72)

RBTiki Barber (83) · Ron Dayne (72) · Joe Montgomery (66)

WRAmani Toomer (85) · Ike Hilliard (77) · Joe Jurevicius (73)

TEJeremy Shockey (84) · Pete Mitchell (76)

EDGEMichael Strahan (99) · Jessie Armstead (85) · Kenny Holmes (80)

DTKeith Hamilton (85) · Cornelius Griffin (77) · Lance Legree (71)

LBMicheal Barrow (79) · Dhani Jones (76) · Corey Widmer (68)

CBJason Sehorn (80) · Emmanuel McDaniel (80) · Will Allen (77)

SPercy Ellsworth (80) · Shaun Williams (79) · Sam Garnes (76)

Series result — Carolina Panthers win 4-0

Game 1: Carolina Panthers 39-30

Game 2: Carolina Panthers 35-28

Game 3: Carolina Panthers 21-19

Game 4: Carolina Panthers 29-28

Think the sim got it wrong? These exact eras can appear in your spins — draft one yourself and prove it.