Cincinnati Bengals (2019-2024) vs Indianapolis Colts (2009-2013)

A simulated 7-game series between two all-time rosters, scored by our era-adjusted rating model. Cincinnati Bengals take it 4-2.

Cincinnati Bengals · 2019-2024

Squad power 85.8 · headliner Trey Hendrickson '24 (97)

QBJoe Burrow (84) · Andy Dalton (72) · Jake Browning (72)

RBJoe Mixon (83) · Chase Brown (77) · Giovani Bernard (71)

WRJa'Marr Chase (96) · Tee Higgins (81) · Tyler Boyd (79)

TEC.J. Uzomah (74) · Mike Gesicki (74) · Tyler Eifert (71)

EDGETrey Hendrickson (97) · Carlos Dunlap (82) · Carl Lawson (82)

DTLarry Ogunjobi (84) · B.J. Hill (79) · Geno Atkins (75)

LBLogan Wilson (80) · Nick Vigil (71) · Josh Bynes (69)

CBCam Taylor-Britt (87) · Dax Hill (79) · Chidobe Awuzie (78)

SJessie Bates (86) · Vonn Bell (81) · Geno Stone (76)

Indianapolis Colts · 2009-2013

Squad power 82.4 · headliner Robert Mathis '13 (96)

QBPeyton Manning (80) · Andrew Luck (79) · Dan Orlovsky (69)

RBJoseph Addai (77) · Donald Brown (74) · Vick Ballard (72)

WRReggie Wayne (86) · T.Y. Hilton (79) · Pierre Garcon (78)

TEDallas Clark (86) · Jacob Tamme (76) · Coby Fleener (75)

EDGERobert Mathis (96) · Dwight Freeney (89) · Cory Redding (73)

DTEric Foster (79) · Daniel Muir (74) · Tyler Brayton (71)

LBJerrell Freeman (78) · Clint Session (75) · Gary Brackett (74)

CBJacob Lacey (80) · Kelvin Hayden (77) · Vontae Davis (74)

SDarius Butler (79) · Antoine Bethea (78) · Melvin Bullitt (69)

Series result — Cincinnati Bengals win 4-2

Game 1: Indianapolis Colts 23-17

Game 2: Cincinnati Bengals 36-26

Game 3: Indianapolis Colts 28-26

Game 4: Cincinnati Bengals 30-26

Game 5: Cincinnati Bengals 37-27

Game 6: Cincinnati Bengals 38-28

Think the sim got it wrong? These exact eras can appear in your spins — draft one yourself and prove it.