New Orleans Saints (2019-2024) vs New York Giants (2014-2018)

A simulated 7-game series between two all-time rosters, scored by our era-adjusted rating model. New Orleans Saints take it 4-2.

New Orleans Saints · 2019-2024

Squad power 85.1 · headliner Michael Thomas '19 (91)

QBDerek Carr (78) · Drew Brees (76) · Andy Dalton (73)

RBAlvin Kamara (89) · Latavius Murray (73) · Jamaal Williams (63)

WRMichael Thomas (91) · Chris Olave (79) · Marquez Callaway (76)

TEJared Cook (85) · Juwan Johnson (77) · Foster Moreau (73)

EDGETrey Hendrickson (91) · Cameron Jordan (89) · Marcus Davenport (81)

DTDavid Onyemata (80) · Bryan Bresee (79) · Nathan Shepherd (73)

LBDemario Davis (86) · Kaden Elliss (72) · Pete Werner (69)

CBPaulson Adebo (86) · Marshon Lattimore (83) · Janoris Jenkins (80)

SMalcolm Jenkins (82) · Marcus Williams (81) · Tyrann Mathieu (79)

New York Giants · 2014-2018

Squad power 84 · headliner Landon Collins '16 (90)

QBEli Manning (78)

RBSaquon Barkley (88) · Rashad Jennings (76) · Orleans Darkwa (74)

WROdell Beckham (88) · Rueben Randle (77) · Sterling Shepard (76)

TEEvan Engram (79) · Larry Donnell (75) · Will Tye (71)

EDGEJason Pierre-Paul (87) · Robert Ayers (84) · Olivier Vernon (84)

DTJohnathan Hankins (82) · Damon Harrison (78) · B.J. Hill (77)

LBAlec Ogletree (78) · Jameel McClain (76) · Uani' Unga (69)

CBDominique Rodgers-Cromartie (88) · Janoris Jenkins (81) · Prince Amukamara (76)

SLandon Collins (90) · Antrel Rolle (80) · Curtis Riley (78)

Series result — New Orleans Saints win 4-2

Game 1: New York Giants 29-25

Game 2: New Orleans Saints 35-29

Game 3: New York Giants 31-21

Game 4: New Orleans Saints 26-24

Game 5: New Orleans Saints 28-20

Game 6: New Orleans Saints 30-25

Think the sim got it wrong? These exact eras can appear in your spins — draft one yourself and prove it.